It's been a while since I've watched A
History of Violence and I have to say, I have discovered some flaws
that I was able to overlook when I first saw it. There are spoilers
from here on.
Let me first revisit what I thought and
continue to think makes this movie good: The fight scenes are great:
Well choreographed to give you a sense of how crazy or well-trained
Viggo Mortensen's character, Tom/Joey, was.
Then the scene where Tom finally gives
in to Joey is a testament to Mortensen's acting skills. Some people
don't see Joey until Tom says “I should've killed you back in
Philly,” but, if you pay attention, during the driveway standoff,
Tom's innocent-family-man's face changes to a knowing smirk. It's a
Bruce-Lee-like transformation, and it is masterfully done. The
contrast in those two characters played by the same actor, the
movie's screeching-turn transition makes this movie intriguing,
although there are some annoying elements.
The little girl is a space cadet. That
scene between her mom and Fogarty in the mall? I've been in a similar
situation when I was little and I was scared beyond belief that my
mom was squaring up against a scary man. Space Girl hops on a nearby
kiddie ride completely oblivious of the danger she could potentially
face. That was annoying.
Next, the teenage son who blows up
after the last straw of being bullied by an alpha-male jock character
and finding out his dad is a killing machine. Before that
scene he was silly teenager, taking bullying like a pro, hanging out
with the questionable girl in school, and being cynical about the
world with no real reason. This line came out of no where:
“Eventually, we uh, grow up, we get jobs, we have affairs and
become alcoholics.” What a nice and perfect life he had lived up
until finding out about his dad. That odd line wasn't even an ironic.
Bad writing or poor time management led
to the worst scene of the movie: The conversation between Joey and,
his brother, Richie in the Philadelphia mansion. They had plenty of
time to do some kind of montage or voiceover to recount for the
audience who Joey was and the things he had done, but instead they
did one of those catch-the-audience-up conversations that usually
work best on television shows, but was placed in this otherwise
pretty good movie.
A discussion with my BFF turned up
another idea: Tom and Edie Stall raised their annoying children in a
safe-and-rosy-environment, not preparing them for a bigger world
where violence lives and can stop into their diner, home or school at
any time. So that's another thing, about this movie: The rude
awakening every member of the Stall family gets when Tom's history of
violence becomes apparent. Hooray! I got to use the title in my
review!
I'm giving this movie 3 stars ***
because I like it, and it is one of the movies that I will watch
over and over again.
I own this DVD.